Smart Discounting for Indian D2C e-commerce: Automating Pricing Strategies across Platforms

‍

‍Discounting in Indian ecommerce is a DOUBLE-EDGED SWORD. 

Slash prices too much, and your margins bleed. Offer too little, and customers abandon their carts.

Somewhere between burning money for conversions and protecting profitability, there’s a sweet spot—one that smart D2C brands must find if they want to scale sustainably.

1. The Cost of Discounting: What’s at Stake?

‍

Most brands underestimate how much revenue they lose due to excessive discounting. Let's break it down with an example:

💡 Key Insight: If your net profit margin is 20%, running a 20% discount without volume growth means zero profit. That’s not a promotion; that’s a charity.

For sustainable discounting, you need to answer:

1️⃣ How many extra units must you sell to cover the margin loss?
2️⃣ Which customer segments actually need a discount to convert?
3️⃣ At what point does discounting lead to price dependency?

2. The ‘Promotional Lifecycle’ of a D2C Brand

Discounting starts as a growth hack but often turns into a profit killer. Here’s how most brands fall into the trap:

1️⃣ Launch Phase – Heavy discounts to acquire first customers.
2️⃣ Growth Phase – Sales grow, but discounting becomes habit-forming.
3️⃣ Stagnation Phase – Customers only buy during sales. Profits start eroding.
4️⃣ Discount Dependency – You need to offer higher discounts just to maintain revenue.
5️⃣ Brand Devaluation – The brand loses pricing power. Customers stop buying at full price.

This cycle is dangerous, but avoidable if you set up a structured discounting strategy.

🚀 The 3 Core Pillars of Smart Discounting:

Instead of offering blanket discounts, build a system that incentivises full-price purchases and rewards only the right customers with discounts.

1️⃣ Customer Segmentation – Not every buyer needs a discount. Identify who does.
2️⃣ Purchase Behaviour Analysis – Study buying patterns to understand when discounts drive conversions.
3️⃣ Profit-Driven Discounting – Ensure every discount protects your margins.

These three pillars ensure that every rupee spent on discounting actually drives sustainable growth instead of just boosting short-term sales.

3. Who Actually Needs a Discount? Customer Segmentation for Smarter Promotions

If you’re offering flat discounts to everyone, you’re throwing money into a fire. Not all customers need a discount to convert. The challenge is identifying who actually does and tailoring your discounts accordingly.

Common Mistake:
A brand offers a 15% off coupon to everyone who visits their site. A customer who was already ready to pay full price now happily applies the coupon—you just lost 15% for no reason.

The smarter approach? Segment customers based on behaviour and intent.

📌 The 5 Key Customer Segments for Smart Discounting:

1️⃣ Full-Price Buyers (No Discount Needed 🚀)

• These customers buy regardless of discounts.
• Example: A customer who always shops new arrivals and doesn’t wait for sales.
• Strategy: Keep them engaged with early access to collections, not discounts.

2️⃣ Deal Seekers (Discount Needed ✅)

• They only buy during sales.
• Example: A customer who adds to cart and waits for festive discounts.
• Strategy: Instead of giving blanket discounts, offer limited-time urgency-based deals (e.g., 24-hour flash sale).

3️⃣ Cart Abandoners (Targeted Discount 🎯)

• They add products but don’t complete the purchase.
• Example: A user abandons a ₹2,500 cart.
• Strategy: Use tiered discounts (e.g., ₹200 off ₹2,500+, ₹500 off ₹5,000+) to encourage higher spend.

4️⃣ First-Time Visitors (Acquisition Discount 👋)

• New users who need an incentive to try your brand.
• Example: A user who landed from Instagram ads but isn’t converting.
• Strategy: Offer a small first-time discount (e.g., 10% off) and guide them into post-purchase retention loops.

5️⃣ Loyal Customers (Retention Discounts 🏆)

• Repeat buyers who deserve rewards.
• Example: A user who has purchased 5+ times in 6 months.
• Strategy: Instead of discounts, offer exclusive perks like free shipping, early access, or VIP pricing.

Key Learning: If you don’t segment your discounts, you’re giving away money to people who don’t need it.

4. The Science of Discount Effectiveness: A/B Testing Your Strategy

Every brand needs to test and optimise its discounting. Here’s how:

🔬 Step 1: Set up A/B tests

• Group A: Shown a ₹500-off discount
• Group B: Shown a "10% off" offer
• Measure which drives better conversions without eroding profits.

📊 Step 2: Analyse Purchase Patterns

• Do repeat customers always wait for sales?
• Are new customers converting only when discounts are applied?

🔄 Step 3: Adapt & Adjust

• If discounts become necessary for every purchase, reduce frequency to reset customer expectations.

📉 Fact Check:

🔹 60% of customers will wait up to 3 months for a discount.
🔹 28% of Indian online shoppers only purchase during sales events.
🔹 Brands that run frequent deep discounts see a 25% lower retention rate compared to those that use strategic discounting.

5. Discounting Across the Customer Journey: Pre-Purchase, Purchase & Post-Purchase

Now that we know who actually needs a discount, let’s map out a discounting strategy across the entire customer journey. The goal? Maximise conversions without eroding margins.

A) Pre-Purchase: Warming Up Potential Buyers (Without Giving Away Too Much)

At this stage, customers are in "research mode." They’re browsing, comparing, and often looking for the best deal. Instead of instantly throwing discounts at them, use data to decide who actually needs a discount.

📌 Tactics for Pre-Purchase Discounting:

B) Purchase Stage: Converting Intent into Sales Without Devaluing the Brand

Once customers add items to their cart, they’re already considering buying. At this point, your discounting should push them towards completing the purchase—without cutting too deep.

📌 Tactics for Purchase-Stage Discounting:

C) Post-Purchase: Retaining Customers Without Over-Discounting

The biggest mistake brands make? Training customers to expect discounts.

Instead of constant discounts, create a system where loyalty and engagement are rewarded.

📌 Tactics for Post-Purchase Discounting:

🔑 Key Takeaways

✔️ Pre-purchase: Identify high-intent users before offering discounts.
✔️ Purchase stage: Use urgency, tiered pricing, and prepaid discounts to boost AOV.
✔️ Post-purchase: Reward loyalty without training customers to expect constant discounts.

The Math of Discounting: How Much Can You Actually Afford to Give Away?

Discounts drive sales, but how much can you afford to discount without eating into your profits? Most brands don’t run the numbers and end up in a discounting death spiral—offering bigger and bigger discounts until margins are gone.

Let’s break down the math, with real-world data, profit calculations, and discounting strategies that actually work.

6. Understanding Your Margins: The Discounting Break-Even Formula

Before slapping a 20% discount on every product, ask yourself: Can my margins handle it?

Let’s say you sell a product for ₹1,500.

• COGS (Cost of Goods Sold): ₹600
• Marketing & Operational Costs: ₹500
• Profit Before Discounts: ₹400
• Profit Margin: 26.6%

Now, if you run a 20% discount, here’s what happens:

At a 30% discount, you're selling at a loss. The break-even discount is 26%—beyond this, you start bleeding money.

Key Insight: Every brand has a different break-even point based on its cost structure. If you don’t calculate it, you’re gambling with your business.

A) The Volume vs. Discount Tradeoff: How Much Do You Need to Sell to Compensate?

Many brands think: "If I offer a 20% discount, I’ll make up for it with higher sales." But do the numbers actually support this?

Example Calculation:

If you cut prices by 30%, you need a 43% increase in sales just to maintain revenue. But more sales also mean higher logistics, packaging, and customer support costs.

Key Insight: Discounting without tracking its impact on volume is dangerous. If you don’t hit the increased sales target, you’ve lost both revenue and margins.

B) Smart Discounting Strategies: Protect Profits While Driving Sales

So, how do you increase conversions without cutting too deep? Use discounting strategically instead of making it your default sales driver.

🔄 Strategy 1: Elastic Pricing—Adjust Based on Demand

Instead of flat 20% off site-wide, create data-driven discounting loops.

• High-Demand Products? Low discounts. Example: If a product sells well even at full price, don’t discount it.
• Low-Demand or Seasonal Products? Higher discounts. Example: If summer stock is unsold in August, clear it out at a higher discount.

📊 Strategy 2: Dynamic Discounting Based on Customer Behavior

Track how customers shop and personalise discounts instead of mass discounting.

🚀 Strategy 3: Use AI & Customer Data to Predict Discount Needs

Brands like Nike, Zara, and Ajio use AI-driven discounting to predict price sensitivity.

• Customers who always buy during sales? Show them only during sale periods—don’t waste discounts on them year-round.
• Customers who buy at full price? Don’t offer them discounts at all—instead, offer free shipping or a free add-on.

📌 Case Study: Tata Cliq’s AI Discounting Model

• 40% of Tata Cliq’s buyers were discount-reliant.
• They implemented predictive AI discounting—offering low discounts to high-LTV customers and deep discounts to price-sensitive ones.
• Result? +18% profit margins & reduced blanket discounting by 30%.

Key Takeaways: Discounting Without Losing Your Shirt

✔️ Know your break-even discount—beyond which, you're losing money.
✔️ Track sales volume increases—if a 20% discount doesn’t bring at least 25% more sales, it’s not working.
✔️ Use AI & purchase behaviour to target discounts only where needed.
✔️ Avoid blanket discounting—instead, use elastic pricing, tiered offers, and loyalty-based incentives.

Examples: How Brands Are Using Smart Discounting

1. boAt

• Kind of Discount: Personalised, Intent-based dynamic discounting
  
• Data Utilised: Real-time behavioral signals (exit intent, scroll depth, session time, cart abandonment signals)
  
• Execution Method:
  
  
  • AI/ML Algorithms: Used Intent-Based Promotions leveraging AI/ML to predict shopper intent and offer personalised discounts accordingly, where only users likely to drop off received a discount pop-up.
  • Selective Discounting: Targeted discounts were provided only to users less likely to convert without them, avoiding blanket promotions.
  • Digital Advertising: Utilised YouTube TrueView for Reach ads and Google Display Network with catchy GIFs to maximise reach and engagement.
  • Integrated across site and retargeting journeys.
    
    
• Benefits:
  
  
  • Increased Conversion Rates: Achieved a 25% increase in conversion rates.
  • Reduced Cart Abandonment: Experienced a 10% reduction in cart abandonment.
  • Lowered Discount Costs: Decreased average discount from 18% to 6%, preserving profit margins.
  • Enhanced Brand Interest: Noted a 158.7% lift in brand interest.
  • Improved Product Interest: Observed a 15.5% increase in product interest.
    
    
• Effectiveness: High — preserved margins while improving CVR. A perfect case of less is more with discounts. The personalised approach led to significant improvements in key performance metrics, indicating effective targeting and resource utilisation.

2. Nykaa

• Kind of Discount: Discount suppression (aka: strategic no-discounting) for certain SKUs
  
  
• Data Utilised: SKU-level performance data, purchase frequency, new season trends
  
  
• Execution Method:
  
  
  • No discount on private labels & fresh launches
  • 20% of all GMV comes from 0-discount SKUs
    
    
• Benefits:
  
  
  • Grew Q4 net profit 3x to ₹6.93 Cr
  • Revenue up 28% YoY (₹1668 Cr)
    
    
• Effectiveness: Very high — showing that you don’t always need a discount to grow if your brand + assortment strategy is strong.
  
  

3. Mamaearth

• Kind of Discount: Personalised email discounts
  
  
• Data Utilised: RFM segmentation (Recency, Frequency, Monetary), cart behavior, email engagement
  
  
• Execution Method:
  
  
  • Trigger-based offers via email: e.g., 10% extra if you abandoned cart with 2+ products
  • Used automation tools (likely WebEngage/Clevertap stack)
    
    
• Benefits:
  
  
  
  • +32% Open Rate
  • +22% Click-through Rate
    
    
• Effectiveness: Moderate-High — especially useful for reactivation + cart recovery

Mamaearth’s Review Incentives

• 50% of buyers don’t leave reviews unless incentivised.
• Mamaearth launched a ₹100-off-for-reviews campaign. This boosted review volume by 38% and increased repeat purchases.

4. The Man Company

• Kind of Discount: Cross-sell/upsell discounts for existing customers
  
  
• Data Utilised: Past purchase behavior, LTV cohort data
  
  
• Execution Method:
  
  
  • Recommended grooming combos based on last order
  • Gave "add-on" discounts (e.g., Add a beard oil at 40% off)
    
    
• Benefits:
  
  • +37% revenue from upsell/cross-sell flows
    
    
• Effectiveness: High — a great example of growing AOV without flat discounting across site

5. Bewakoof

• Kind of Discount: Membership-based exclusive discounts (TriBe) and YouTube Shopping Cards promotions
  
  
• Data Utilised: Customer lifecycle data, cohort churn rates - Customer purchase history, engagement metrics, and demographic information
  
  
• Execution Method:
  
  • ₹99/year membership = 20% off + free shipping + early access
  • Promoted via YouTube Shopping Cards and influencer reviews

- TriBe Membership Program: Offered members up to 20% off on products, free shipping, and early access to new releases, fostering customer loyalty.

- YouTube Shopping Cards: Integrated shopping cards within YouTube TrueView ads to showcase products directly in videos, enabling viewers to purchase seamlessly.

- Influencer Collaborations: Engaged influencers in campaigns like the #24HourChallenge to review and promote products, increasing reach and credibility.

• Benefits:
  
  • Increased Sales: Achieved over 9,000 sales through YouTube campaigns.
  • High Return on Ad Spend (ROAS): Realised a 4x ROAS from YouTube Shopping Cards integration.
  • Enhanced Customer Loyalty: The TriBe program incentivised repeat purchases and strengthened customer relationships.
    
    
• Effectiveness: High — driving retention and predictable revenue through smart bundling of perks, the combination of membership incentives and innovative advertising formats effectively boosted sales and customer engagement.

6. Myntra

Myntra’s Prepaid Incentives

• Myntra noticed that COD orders had 40% higher RTO rates.
• They introduced ₹100 off prepaid orders, which increased prepaid conversions by 18% and cut RTO rates by 23%.

Final Thoughts:

🚀 Discounting is NOT a business strategy—it’s a tool. 

Use it wisely, surgically, and profitably. Otherwise, you’ll be training your customers to never pay full price again

FAQs (Frequently Asked Questions On Smart Discounting for Indian D2C Ecommerce)

1. Why do heavy discounts hurt more than they help?

Because you’re not just slashing prices—you’re slicing into margins, attracting deal hunters, and training customers to never buy at full price. If your repeat rate is low and your AOV doesn’t increase after a discount, you’re basically paying people to shop once and never come back.

2. What’s a smarter way to offer discounts?

Make it contextual, not constant.

• Offer prepaid-only discounts to reduce RTO.
• Push discounts via WhatsApp or email to avoid putting them front and centre for everyone.
• Use first-purchase offers for acquisition and loyalty points or credits for retention.

The idea is: Incentivise the right behaviour, not just the purchase.

3. How do I know if my discounts are actually working?

Track more than just conversions. Look at:

• What % of discounted buyers come back?
• Did the discount increase AOV?
• Was it used by new customers or returning ones?

Discounting without measuring CLTV is just guesswork.

4. What kind of discounting works during sales season in India?

Combo offers and BOGO with a twist.

• Think “Buy 2, Get 1 but only if you prepay.”
• Or “Flat ₹100 off on your second order.”
• Use cart-value based nudges: “₹200 off on orders above ₹1499” works better than 15% off on everything.

During season sales, structure wins over slashing.

5. Should discounts be site-wide or product-specific?

Product-specific always wins in the long run.Site-wide sales are tempting but train customers to delay purchases till the next big drop. Discounting slower-moving or seasonal inventory instead helps push stock without killing brand value.